Should I Reface or Replace My Kitchen Cabinets?

When your kitchen starts looking outdated or worn, updating your cabinets can make a huge difference. However, the dilemma often comes down to whether you should reface or replace your kitchen cabinets. Both options have their own set of advantages and disadvantages, and the best choice depends on factors like budget, kitchen style, and your long-term goals. In this article, we’ll explore both options in detail, so you can make an informed decision.

What Does It Mean to Reface Kitchen Cabinets?

Refacing involves giving your existing cabinet structure a facelift. The core cabinet boxes remain in place, but the doors, drawer fronts, and hardware are replaced or refinished. The process also typically includes applying a veneer or laminate to the cabinet frames.

Steps Involved in Refacing Cabinets

1. Removing Old Doors and Hardware – The existing cabinet doors and hardware are taken off.

2. Veneer Application – A thin veneer or laminate is applied to the exterior surface of the cabinet boxes.

3. Installing New Doors and Drawer Fronts – New doors and drawer fronts, which can be made of wood or laminate, are installed.

4. Replacing Hardware – New hinges, knobs, or pulls are added to complete the look.
   

Benefits of Refacing

• Cost-Effective: Refacing is typically more affordable than a full replacement since the underlying structure of the cabinets stays intact.

• Less Disruption: The process is quicker and causes less disruption to your kitchen, often taking just a few days.

• Eco-Friendly: Refacing reuses your existing cabinet boxes, reducing waste compared to a full replacement.
  

Drawbacks of Refacing

• Limited Structural Changes: If your cabinets are in poor condition structurally, refacing won’t solve that problem.

• Design Limitations: You can't change the layout or size of your cabinets; you’re working with what’s already there.

• Potential Wear: While the exterior gets an update, the interior of your cabinets remains the same, and any damage or wear will persist.
  

What Does It Mean to Replace Kitchen Cabinets?

Replacing your cabinets means completely removing the old cabinetry and installing new ones. This option provides more flexibility in terms of style, layout, and materials but often comes with a higher price tag.

Steps Involved in Replacing Cabinets

1. Removing Old Cabinets – The existing cabinets are fully removed from the walls.

2. Preparing the Space – The area may need repairs or preparation before the new cabinets are installed.

3. Installing New Cabinets – New cabinets are fitted into place, which could involve adjusting or redesigning the layout.

4. Finishing Touches – Once installed, finishing work like installing countertops, backsplashes, and hardware is completed.
   

Benefits of Replacing

• Complete Customization: You have complete freedom to redesign the layout, change the size or shape of cabinets, and choose any material or finish you desire.

• Improved Functionality: You can optimize your kitchen’s storage and flow with modern cabinet features like soft-close drawers or pull-out shelves.

• Longer-Lasting: Replacing your cabinets allows you to address any structural issues and ensures that your cabinetry will last for many years to come.
  

Drawbacks of Replacing

• Higher Cost: Cabinet replacement is a much more significant investment compared to refacing.

• More Time-Consuming: Replacing cabinets can take weeks, especially if additional remodeling is needed.

• Disruption: Since your kitchen is out of commission during the installation, this option can be more inconvenient.
  

Factors to Consider: Should You Reface or Replace?

1. Budget

If you're working with a limited budget, refacing is usually the more cost-effective option. However, if your cabinets are old and showing signs of structural damage, replacing might be the better long-term investment.

2. Cabinet Condition

Examine the condition of your current cabinets. If the cabinet boxes are still in good shape but just outdated, refacing can refresh the space without the need for a full replacement. But if the cabinets are warped, have water damage, or are falling apart, replacing is likely the best choice.

3. Desired Aesthetic and Functionality

Refacing is ideal if you’re happy with your kitchen layout and simply want to update the look. If you’re seeking a complete redesign of your kitchen, replacement will offer the flexibility to achieve your vision. Additionally, replacing allows for modern upgrades, like installing taller cabinets or maximizing storage with custom inserts.

4. Time and Disruption

Refacing your cabinets takes less time and causes minimal disruption to your daily life. If you’re in a hurry or don’t want to deal with a long renovation, refacing is the faster, easier route. On the other hand, replacing your cabinets requires more time and effort, which may be inconvenient if you’re using your kitchen frequently.

5. Long-Term Plans

If you plan on staying in your home for the long haul, investing in replacement cabinets may provide more value in terms of both functionality and resale. However, if you're considering selling soon, refacing your cabinets can offer a fresh look that increases appeal without a large upfront cost.

Cost Comparison: Reface vs. Replace

• Refacing Costs: On average, refacing costs between $1,000 and $9,000, depending on the size of the kitchen and the materials used.

• Replacing Costs: Cabinet replacement can range from $4,000 to $25,000 or more, with higher-end options like custom cabinetry driving up the cost.
  

Which Option Increases Home Value More?

In terms of increasing your home’s value, both refacing and replacing can offer good returns, but it depends on the condition of your kitchen and the local housing market. A full replacement can have a more significant impact on home value if the kitchen is outdated or inefficient, but refacing provides a solid return on investment as well by modernizing the look without the full expense.

How Long Do Each Last?

• Refaced Cabinets: A refaced cabinet can last up to 15–20 years if properly maintained. The new veneer or laminate is durable, but the underlying cabinet box may still age.

• Replaced Cabinets: New cabinets, especially high-quality custom ones, can last upwards of 30 years or more, providing a more long-term solution.
  

Pros and Cons at a Glance

FAQs

1. How long does it take to reface cabinets?

Refacing typically takes 3–5 days, making it a quick solution for a kitchen facelift.

2. Can I reface my cabinets myself?

While DIY refacing is possible, professional installation ensures a high-quality, durable finish.

3. What materials can I choose for refacing?

Common materials for refacing include wood veneers, laminate, and thermofoil.

4. How do I know if my cabinets are in good enough condition to reface?

If your cabinet boxes are structurally sound—meaning no warping, rotting, or major damage—refacing is a good option.

5. Will replacing cabinets increase my home’s resale value?

Yes, new cabinets can improve both the aesthetic appeal and functionality of your kitchen, boosting its resale value.

6. Is it cheaper to replace cabinet doors only?

Replacing just the cabinet doors is less expensive than a full replacement but typically more costly than refacing.

Conclusion

The decision to reface or replace your kitchen cabinets depends on your budget, the condition of your cabinets, and your desired outcome. Refacing is an affordable, quick option that refreshes the look of your kitchen, while replacement offers more customization and long-term benefits. Whichever you choose, updating your cabinets will breathe new life into your kitchen and improve both its functionality and aesthetic appeal. At Northwest Cabinet & Floor, we got you covered whether you want to reface or replace your kitchen & bathroom cabinets. Contact us today for a free quote!